Ah, smell that? That’s the sweet smell of the Grammys coming up! JK…kinda. The biggest night in music is finally upon us—and it’s lookin’ like it’ll be a good one.
But before we cast our bets on who will win and get a head start on the list for the Grammy Sunday snackage next year, we need to address the elephant in the room: the fact that basically no one really, truly knows how the nominees for the Best New Artist category are chosen. I said what I said!
I know this category is hard to understand, because…haven’t some of this year’s nominees been around for literal ages now??? This is true, but since the Recording Academy considers “new” to be pretty fluid, it came up with an entire list of rules to determine who makes the cut and who doesn’t. Let’s be real though—you don’t have time for all the lengthy Academy jargon, so I’ve distilled the rules down to their essence to make it really easy to understand.
Join me as I explain the enigma of this category, so you can be the most knowledgeable among your friends come show night.
First of all, who’s nominated for Best New Artist this year?
Gracie Abrams
Fred again..
Ice Spice
Victoria Monét
Jelly Roll
Coco Jones
Noah Kahan
The War And Treaty
Okay, but does an artist need to be popular to be nominated?
So you’ve looked at all the nominees and there are likely three to five names in the list that you don’t know, and guess what—that’s totally normal. Even though some of these non-pop artists haven't hit your Spotify Daily List, the Recording Academy believes they have made their way into the “public consciousness” in a significant and unique way during the eligibility period.
Paras Griffin//Getty Images
To put this in layman’s terms, an artist needs to leave a lasting impact on the music industry during a year when they are eligible to be nominated. Think: a sudden entrance into the mainstream, critically acclaimed albums, viral videos, and, of course, musical talent beyond imagination.
When was the 2024 Grammys eligibility period?
This year’s eligibility period took place from October 1, 2022 to September 15, 2023. All your faves who are nominated in this category came to prominence and put out banging music during this critical time frame.
What makes someone eligible for Best New Artist?
Here’s where things begin to get a *little* tricky, so pay close attention! An artist must have a minimum of five singles/tracks OR a complete album to be eligible for Best New Artist. An artist hoping to be considered can also have a maximum of 30 singles/tracks OR three complete albums, previously released. Got it?
If an artist has more than the maximum (or less than the minimum), they are deemed ineligible for the Best New Artist award, even if they had a “significant impact” on the musical landscape and have come into the public consciousnesses during an eligibility period.
Also, something important to remember: Even if an artist hoping to be nominated meets the Grammys numerical release criteria (see above), they can still be ineligible if they start getting widespread, mainstream attention before the year they’re hoping to be nominated. Basically, it’s all about timing!
Jason Koerner//Getty Images
Take Ice Spice, as an example. She released her smash-hit single “Munch” in 2022, which was two years ago. Even though this song by definition is “old,” Ice didn’t receive major media attention until 2023 when it went viral on TikTok and starting hitting radio stations.
Then, that same year, she released her EP, Like..? to critical acclaim. And the music industry? Impacted! Because Ice also released a few singles (“Princess Diana,” “Deli,” “Barbie World” with Nicki Minaj, and Taylor Swift's “Karma” remix to name a few) during the eligibility period, she was able to snag a Best New Artist nomination this year.
How many times can someone be nominated for Best New Artist?
Musicians are allowed to be nominated in this category a maximum of three times—solo, in a group, or a combination of the two. Allow me to deconstruct this for ya with a ~hypothetical~ example.
Christopher Polk//Getty Images
If a musician was in a band and said band got three Best New Artist nominations but then the member chose to leave and pursue a solo career, they could not get a Best New Artist nomination as a solo artist.
In the words of the Recording Academy, “Being previously considered three times either as a solo artist, in a previous band, or some mixture of the two means an artist is not eligible for Best New Artist consideration.” Sorry, Grammy hopefuls, I don’t make the rules!
More Grammys Gold For Ya 🏆🏆🏆
ncG1vNJzZmivp6x7pLvSpqapp5yewaK6jZympmeVo8GmvtOaoKellaPBcLnUrKCcZ5FofXaAmGptbWeXp66uudisZJudo6l6r7HWZpirrJmowW6x16mjmqGemrFw